As a psychologist, I often encounter situations where the decision-making abilities of older adults or individuals with cognitive impairments are called into question. In these cases, it's crucial to carefully assess not only the individual's capacity but also the presence of any undue influence. Undue influence can be complicated, as there are many interpersonal and relationship factors that come into play, as well as personal values that are hard for outsiders to quantify. My role in these cases is to provide capacity assessment and evaluate the totality of a person’s situation and decisions to help determine whether undue influence is an issue.
What is Undue Influence?
Undue influence occurs when a person uses improper methods to persuade another person to make a decision they would not otherwise make. This can involve:
Coercion: Using threats, intimidation, or pressure to force someone to make a decision.
Manipulation: Using deception, flattery, or emotional appeals to exploit someone's vulnerabilities.
Isolation: Isolating the individual from trusted friends, family, or advisors.
Exploitation: Taking advantage of the individual's financial, emotional, or physical needs for personal gain.
Signs of Potential Undue Influence:
Sudden and unexplained changes in behavior or lifestyle.
Isolation from family and friends.
Unusual or suspicious financial transactions.
Rapidly changing wills or other legal documents.
A new and dominant relationship with a caregiver or other individual.
The individual expressing fear or anxiety about making decisions.
The Role of the Psychologist in Assessing Capacity and Undue Influence
Psychologists play a vital role in assessing both capacity and the potential for undue influence. Our assessments typically involve:
Thorough clinical interviews: Assessing the individual's cognitive functioning, including memory, attention, judgment, and decision-making abilities. This can also include asking about history, values, and past decision-making.
Review of medical records: Examining medical history, medications, and any existing diagnoses.
Collateral interviews: Gathering information from family members, caregivers, and other relevant individuals.
Observation of the individual's behavior: Observing their interactions with others and assessing their overall mental state.
Distinguishing Between Capacity Limitations and Undue Influence
It's important to distinguish between genuine capacity limitations and the effects of undue influence.
Capacity limitations: These may involve cognitive impairments such as dementia, Alzheimer's disease, or other neurological conditions that affect an individual's ability to make sound judgments.
Undue influence: This involves external pressures or manipulations that exploit an individual's vulnerabilities, regardless of their cognitive abilities.
Ethical Considerations
Maintaining confidentiality: Psychologists have an ethical obligation to maintain confidentiality in all interactions with clients. However, there may be situations where it is necessary to breach confidentiality to protect the individual from harm.
Avoiding conflicts of interest: Psychologists must avoid any situations that could create a conflict of interest, such as having a personal or financial relationship with any party involved in the case.
Respecting the individual's autonomy: While protecting vulnerable adults is essential, it's crucial to respect their autonomy and right to make their own decisions whenever possible. This balance is at the heart of any capacity assessment.
Assessing capacity and identifying potential undue influence are complex and multifaceted tasks. Psychologists play a critical role in these evaluations, providing objective and unbiased assessments that can help protect vulnerable adults from exploitation and ensure that their rights and best interests are upheld.
Disclaimer: This blog post is for informational purposes only and should not be considered medical or legal advice.
Start Working with A Therapist for Older Adults in LA
If you or a loved one need support navigating cognitive concerns, decision-making, or undue influence, a therapist for older adults in LA can help. Contact Dr. Reger to schedule a consultation and ensure peace of mind for you and your family. You can start the therapy process by following these simple steps:
Contact (424) 262-1925 to schedule your appointment
Meet with Dr. Reger for an assessment
Start finding the support you deserve!
Other Services Offered by Dr. Reger in Los Angeles, CA
I am happy to offer support with a variety of services in addition to counseling for older adults. I also offer a variety of neuropsychological assessments in addition to ADHD testing. I am happy to offer capacity assessments, neuropsychological and psychological assessments, pre-surgical assessments, and med-legal evaluations. In addition to evaluations, I also provide individual therapy, and mental health consultations and presentations. Visit my blog for more help today!